Unsure How to Show Appreciation Beyond Pay?

Download our Employee Appreciation Toolkit for helpful tips, tricks and advice on:

• Recognising employees in ways that actually resonate and drive engagement across your team
  
• Tying appreciation to performance so top talent feels seen, valued, and motivated to stay
  
• Boosting morale with creative, low-effort ideas that make a real impact.

How To Create A Performance Management Process That Actually Works

An effective performance management process is one of the most powerful tools a business has to engage its people, develop talent, and drive results. In a world of hybrid teams, evolving employee expectations, and rapid business change, organisations like yours need more than annual appraisals to keep their people motivated and aligned.

The way we manage performance is about creating a culture of continuous feedback, coaching, and recognition that supports people at every stage of their journey. It’s also about clarity – defining expectations, measuring progress, and rewarding success in a way that feels fair, human, and impactful.

In this guide, we’ll explore the full performance management process and cycle – from setting objectives and providing feedback to using data, tools, and culture to create meaningful, measurable progress. Whether you’re building a new framework or refreshing an outdated one, this is your blueprint for performance that actually performs.

What Is Performance Management?

At its core, performance management is the structured, ongoing process of aligning individual performance with organisational goals, and making sure that employees have the support they need to succeed.

A performance management process includes setting clear expectations, monitoring progress, giving feedback, and recognising achievements. It makes it easier for employees to understand how their work contributes to the bigger picture, and it gives managers a framework to coach, support, and guide their teams effectively.

It’s also important to distinguish between performance management and performance appraisal. Appraisals are typically one-off, formal reviews (often annual) whereas performance management is a continuous, strategic process. In today’s hybrid workplaces, that continuous model is what truly drives engagement, development, and results.

The Performance Management Cycle Explained

A strong performance management system doesn’t happen by chance, it follows a clear cycle that makes employees feel they are supported, accountable, and continuously improving. While every organisation may put its own spin on the details, most performance management cycles follow four key stages:

Planning

This is where everything starts. During the planning phase, managers and employees work together to set clear, achievable objectives. These should be aligned to wider business goals and grounded in the individual’s role. Many organisations use SMART goals (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound – we will cover this more later on) to ensure clarity and focus. Planning also includes identifying any development needs, setting expectations, and outlining how success will be measured.

Monitoring

Performance is an ongoing process of tracking progress, identifying roadblocks, and offering support. This stage is all about regular check-ins (weekly, monthly, or quarterly) to keep things on track. It allows managers to spot issues early, provide feedback in real time, and adjust goals if needed.

Reviewing

Traditionally, this is where the formal appraisal happens, but in a continuous performance model, the review stage is far less daunting. By this point, regular conversations and coaching should have made feedback routine. The review is a chance to reflect on what’s been achieved, identify growth areas, and recognise success. It’s also an opportunity to look ahead and reset goals for the next cycle.

Rewarding

Acknowledging progress and performance is critical to motivation. This final stage involves both financial recognition (like bonuses or pay increases) and non-financial rewards (like praise, opportunities for progression, or extra responsibilities). Celebrating success reinforces the behaviours and outcomes you want to see and shows employees their work matters.

Setting Objectives & Measuring Performance

If performance management is the engine, clear objectives are the fuel. Without well-defined goals, it’s impossible for employees to know what’s expected and equally hard for managers to evaluate success.

Setting SMART Objectives

Effective performance objectives are aligned with the overall business strategy and tailored to each individual’s role and development needs. The SMART framework is widely used to structure goals that are:

Specific – clearly state what needs to be achieved
Measurable – include tangible outcomes or KPIs
Achievable – realistic given time, resources, and skill level
Relevant – aligned with team and organisational priorities
Time-bound – include clear deadlines

For example, “Improve customer satisfaction scores by 10% by the end of Q3 through improved response times and training” is far more actionable than “Improve customer service.”

Aligning Goals Across Teams

When goal-setting is done well, individual objectives connect with broader team and organisational goals. This alignment helps employees see the bigger picture and feel more connected to the company’s mission, which in turn drives engagement and accountability.

Measuring Performance

Once objectives are in place, you need a system for measuring them. This can include:

Quantitative metrics (e.g. sales figures, customer satisfaction scores, project completion rates)
Qualitative feedback (from peers, clients, or direct reports)
Behavioural indicators (e.g. collaboration, initiative, adaptability)

The key is to use a balanced approach that captures both results and behaviours, giving a full picture of performance rather than relying solely on numbers.

By making expectations crystal clear and tracking progress meaningfully, organisations can build a culture of fairness, identify top performers, and support those who need development, all of which feed into the next phase of the performance cycle: feedback and coaching.

The Role of Coaching & Feedback

Feedback is the heartbeat of performance management. It’s how employees grow, how trust is built, and how organisations stay agile. Yet many businesses still struggle to create a culture where feedback flows consistently and constructively.

From One-Off Reviews to Ongoing Conversations

Traditional performance management relied heavily on annual appraisals, often with minimal interaction in between. Today, that model is widely considered outdated. Instead, continuous performance conversations, like regular, informal check-ins between managers and employees, are becoming the norm.

These conversations create space for:

Real-time recognition of progress
Quick course correction when things go off track
Shared problem-solving and coaching
Ongoing alignment with goals

Frequent feedback boosts confidence and strengthens relationships between employees and managers.

Coaching as a Core Management Skill

Effective performance management is about evaluating people and helping them grow. That’s why coaching is now considered a core skill for managers.

Coaching focuses on:

Asking questions instead of giving orders
Helping employees find their own solutions
Encouraging self-reflection and ownership
Supporting skill development, not just results

A coaching-based approach transforms the dynamic between managers and team members, making performance management feel collaborative rather than top-down.

The Two-Way Street of Feedback

Importantly, feedback should go both ways. Employees should be encouraged to share their own perspectives on their performance, their goals, and the support they’re receiving. This builds trust, drives engagement, and helps managers improve too!

When feedback is embedded into daily culture, it removes the fear factor. Instead of being something to
dread, feedback becomes a tool for learning, connection, and ongoing improvement.

Performance Reviews & Improvement Plans

While continuous feedback forms the foundation of effective performance management, formal performance reviews still play a key role in consolidating progress, setting future direction, and ensuring accountability. But their purpose, and their execution, has evolved.

Modernising the Performance Review

Traditional annual reviews often felt like a formality: time-consuming, disconnected from day-to-day work, and stressful for employees. Today, organisations are shifting toward lightweight, forward-focused reviews that build on regular check-ins.

Modern performance reviews are:

Two-way: both the manager and the employee come prepared with insights
Development-driven: focused on growth, not just evaluation
Linked to goals: reviewing progress toward agreed objectives
Documented: creating a shared record of the conversation and outcomes

When reviews are seen as an opportunity, not a judgment, they become a powerful tool for engagement and planning.

Addressing Underperformance: Improvement Plans

Not all performance conversations are easy and when an employee is struggling, structure becomes essential. That’s where Performance Improvement Plans (PIPs) come in.

A PIP is a formal, time-bound plan that:

Clearly outlines the areas where performance is falling short
Defines specific goals and expectations for improvement
Provides support, resources, and regular check-ins
Includes measurable milestones and review dates

A PIP should always be positioned as a support mechanism, not a punishment. The aim is to help the employee get back on track and most do, with the right coaching and clarity.

When Performance Doesn’t Improve

If, after a fair and well-supported process, performance still doesn’t improve, the final stage may involve disciplinary action or termination. While this is always a last resort, handling it professionally – and with documentation – is essential to protect both the employee and the organisation.

A clear, consistent approach to reviews and improvement plans ensures fairness, reinforces expectations, and protects your company culture from the ripple effects of unresolved underperformance.

6. Rewarding and Recognising Performance

Recognition is one of the most powerful drivers of motivation, yet it’s often overlooked or reserved only for end-of-year reviews. A high-performing culture celebrates. Recognising and rewarding great work reinforces the behaviours you want to see more of and makes people feel seen, valued, and appreciated.

Why Recognition Matters

When employees feel their efforts are acknowledged, they’re more likely to:

• Stay engaged and motivated
• Take ownership of their work
• Go above and beyond
• Remain loyal to the organisation

In fact, consistent recognition has been linked to better performance, lower turnover, and stronger workplace culture.

Financial vs. Non-Financial Rewards

While pay increases and bonuses have their place, reward strategies should go beyond the payslip. A comprehensive recognition approach includes:

• Monetary rewards: bonuses, salary increases, commission, gift cards
• Career progression: promotions, new responsibilities, personal development opportunities
• Non-financial recognition: public praise, thank-you messages, peer-to-peer shout-outs, or wellbeing-focused gifts

Sometimes, a personalised thank-you or a surprise gesture can have more impact than a standardised bonus.

Making Recognition Continuous

Recognition should be baked into the everyday culture. Tools like employee recognition platforms or even regular team meetings can provide simple ways to give timely, authentic praise. Recognition should be:

• Specific – say what was done well
• Timely – give it soon after the achievement
• Relevant – link it to team or company values

By embedding recognition throughout your performance management process, you create a positive feedback loop that reinforces strong performance, boosts morale, and supports retention.

7. Roles and Responsibilities in Performance Management

Performance management is a shared responsibility that spans every level of an organisation, and shouldn’t just be HR’s responsibility. For it to work effectively, each stakeholder must understand and own their role in the process.

The Role of Line Managers

Managers are on the front lines of performance management. They are the ones who:

• Set clear expectations and objectives
• Provide ongoing feedback and coaching
• Conduct performance reviews
• Recognise and reward achievements
• Support employees through challenges and development

A manager’s ability to build trust, hold meaningful conversations, and lead with empathy has a direct impact on team performance. Yet, many managers aren’t trained for these responsibilities, which is why manager development is so important to a successful performance culture.

The Role of HR

HR provides the framework and tools to support effective performance management. This includes:

• Designing and communicating the performance process
• Training managers on coaching, feedback, and review techniques
• Ensuring fairness and consistency across teams
• Supporting improvement plans and managing risk
• Aligning performance management with other people strategies (like L&D and rewards)

HR also plays a key role in embedding performance management into the wider culture, making it feel less like an HR process and more like a business-critical function.

The Role of Employees

Employees aren’t passive recipients in this process – they’re active participants. Great performance management invites employees to:

• Understand their goals and how they contribute to company success
• Seek and respond to feedback
• Reflect on their own performance
• Share their aspirations and challenges
• Take ownership of their development and growth

When employees feel empowered and involved, performance management becomes a tool for growth.

Principles of Good Performance Management

It’s important to remember, a performance management process is only as effective as the principles it’s built on! Without a strong foundation, even the best tools and systems will fail to engage employees or deliver results. The most successful organisations design their approach around a clear set of values that guide how performance is supported, evaluated, and rewarded.

Transparency

Clarity is key. Employees should understand what’s expected of them, how their performance is measured, and how feedback and rewards are decided. When people know the rules of the game, they’re far more likely to play, and win, with confidence.

Fairness and Consistency

Nothing undermines trust in performance management like favouritism, bias, or inconsistency. A good process ensures that:

Goals are fairly set and aligned across roles
Reviews are based on objective evidence, not opinions
Everyone is held to the same standards, regardless of seniority or working location

Consistency doesn’t means that every employee should experience the process as equitable, even if it isn’t a one-size-fits-all approach.

Regularity

Performance management must be ongoing, not annual. Feedback should happen in the moment, goals should be revisited frequently, and check-ins should be part of the rhythm of work. This ensures employees stay engaged, supported, and aligned all year round.

Employee Engagement

The best systems are collaborative, not top-down. Employees should feel like co-creators in their performance journey — involved in setting goals, offering feedback, and shaping their development path. This boosts motivation and creates a sense of ownership.

Development-Oriented

Rather than focusing only on results, good performance management also invests in growth. It asks: What skills does this person need to reach their potential? What support will help them get there? How can we align their development with future business needs? This mindset helps organisations nurture talent, improve retention, and futureproof their teams.

By embedding these principles into your performance management strategy, you create a culture where people feel respected, motivated, and supported — and where performance becomes a pathway to progress, not pressure.

Technology & Tools in Modern Performance Management

It’s no surprise that nowadays, performance management is no longer confined to paper forms or annual spreadsheets. The right technology can transform how performance is tracked, measured, and supported. This helps to make the process more efficient, consistent, and meaningful for everyone involved.

From Admin Burden to Strategic Enablement

Historically, performance management systems were clunky and time-consuming, often creating more admin than impact. But modern platforms are designed to:

Automate reminders for check-ins and reviews
Capture feedback in real time
Align individual goals with team and company objectives
Track progress using dashboards and analytics
Store documentation securely and accessibly

By taking care of the admin, tech frees up HR and managers to focus on what really matters: conversations, coaching, and connection.

Popular Performance Management Tools

There are a growing number of digital solutions designed to support continuous performance management, including.

Workhuman Conversations® – enables frequent feedback, recognition, and check-ins
Lattice – combines performance reviews, OKRs, and employee engagement in one platform
15Five – known for weekly check-ins, pulse surveys, and manager coaching tools
Culture Amp – integrates performance, engagement, and development insights

These platforms help foster better habits, increase visibility, and create a more connected performance culture.

Integrating with the Bigger Picture

Modern tools also integrate with broader HR systems such as learning and development platforms, reward systems, and workforce analytics. This creates a connected view of talent, where performance data feeds into:

Succession planning
Promotions and pay reviews
Training and development priorities
Company-wide goal alignment

Choosing the Right Tool

Technology should support your performance philosophy, but not necessarily control it. When choosing a platform, consider:

Ease of use – will managers and employees actually adopt it?
Customisability – can it reflect your company values and structure?
Data insights – will it help you make better people decisions?
Scalability – can it grow with your organisation?

When done right, performance tech becomes a seamless extension of your culture, helping you embed continuous development, accountability, and recognition into the day-to-day rhythm of your business.

12. Inclusivity, Bias & Legal Considerations

An effective performance management process must be fair, inclusive, and legally compliant. Inconsistent practices, unconscious bias, or lack of accommodations can undermine employee trust and expose organisations to reputational and legal risks.

Addressing Bias in Evaluation

Despite best intentions, performance evaluations can be influenced by unconscious bias, including assumptions based on gender, race, age, working patterns (such as remote vs. in-office), or personality style.

Common types of bias to watch for include:

• Recency bias – focusing only on recent events, not the full review period
• Similarity bias – favouring those who share similar traits or views
• Halo/horns effect – letting one positive or negative trait skew the overall review
• Attribution bias – attributing success to external factors for some, and effort for others

To reduce bias, organisations should:

• Train managers on fair evaluation techniques
• Use structured review forms with specific criteria
• Incorporate 360-degree feedback where appropriate
• Ensure diverse input in high-stakes decisions (e.g. promotions)

Inclusive Performance Practices

Inclusivity means making performance management work for everyone, including neurodiverse employees, those with disabilities, and employees from underrepresented backgrounds. This may involve:

• Adapting goal-setting to suit different communication or work styles
• Offering flexible timelines or formats for reviews
• Providing reasonable adjustments or extra coaching support
• Being mindful of cultural or language differences in feedback delivery

Creating inclusive processes ensures all employees are judged on outcomes and effort, not on how closely they match a traditional “ideal performer” model.

Staying Legally Compliant

In addition to ethical responsibility, there are legal obligations tied to performance management. Poorly handled processes can lead to claims of discrimination, unfair dismissal, or breach of contract.

Key legal considerations include:

• Documentation – keeping accurate, objective records of performance conversations, goals, and outcomes
• Procedural fairness – giving employees clear expectations, notice of concerns, and opportunities to improve
• Equality Act 2010 (UK) – ensuring no employee is disadvantaged due to protected characteristics (e.g. disability, age, sex)
• Data protection – handling performance data in line with GDPR and privacy standards

By embedding fairness and compliance into your performance management approach, you both protect your organisation and create a more inclusive and trusted culture where everyone has the opportunity to succeed.

14. Futureproofing Your Performance Management Strategy

Futureproofing your performance management process means designing for agility, inclusivity, and impact.

Adaptability Is Essential

Gone are the days of rigid annual reviews and one-size-fits-all templates. Today’s organisations must be able to:

• Adapt quickly to market shifts, team restructures, or business pivots
• Tailor performance conversations to suit different roles, working models, and personalities
• Shift focus from short-term task completion to long-term growth, learning, and adaptability

A future-ready performance strategy is flexible, without becoming vague, and responsive to the dynamic nature of modern work.

Supporting Hybrid and Remote Teams

With hybrid and remote working now the norm in many sectors, performance management must bridge the physical distance to maintain clarity, accountability, and connection. That means:

• Setting clear goals and expectations regardless of location
• Maintaining regular, structured check-ins
• Using digital tools for real-time feedback and visibility
• Avoiding proximity bias by measuring outcomes, not presence

Building systems that work for distributed teams improves performance, supports fairness and boosts trust across your workforce.

Designing for Diversity

A futureproofed strategy is inclusive by design. It takes into account different communication styles, cultural contexts, neurodiversity, and access needs. That might mean:

• Offering multiple ways to receive and give feedback (verbal, written, asynchronous)
• Personalising goal-setting approaches
• Ensuring accessible review formats for all employees
• Continuously seeking feedback on how to improve the process itself

By embedding flexibility and inclusivity into your performance model, you build a system that empowers everyone to contribute and grow.

Aligning with the Employee Experience

The next generation of performance management is employee-centric. It connects performance with purpose, personal development, wellbeing, and belonging. Employees want to know:

• How does my work matter?
• Where can I grow?
• Am I recognised for who I am, not just what I do?

Integrating performance with broader employee experience strategies — such as learning and development, mental wellbeing, and DEI, makes the process more meaningful and engaging.

Evolving With Intention

Futureproofing doesn’t mean overhauling everything at once. It’s about continuously improving your approach based on feedback, data, and the changing needs of your people. Keep asking:

• Is our system helping people do their best work?
• Is it fair, flexible, and forward-looking?
• Does it reflect the culture we want to build?

A futureproof performance management strategy isn’t just a process. It’s a commitment to progress, to people, and to building a business that thrives through change.

Rethinking Performance for a Modern Workforce

Performance management is now a dynamic, strategic tool for growth, engagement, and alignment. How we manage performance speaks volumes about how we value our people.

An effective performance management process means setting meaningful goals, having honest conversations, recognising achievements, supporting development, and building trust. It’s about creating a culture where performance is ongoing, inclusive, and embedded into everyday working life.

By aligning your processes with key principles, fairness, clarity, accountability, and adaptability, you create the conditions where people and business can thrive together. Whether you’re building a new framework or improving what you already have, the opportunity is clear: performance management can be more than a process.

It can be a powerful catalyst for connection, culture, and long-term success.